YouTube viewing reveals eerie parallels between ‘The Ninth Guest’ and ‘And Then There Were None’

By Amy Zents

YouTube viewing reveals eerie parallels between ‘The Ninth Guest’ and ‘And Then There Were None’

By Amy Zents

Journal contributor

https://youtu.be/gx9Jtug7Qt0?si=C89bmDw9oCAzCgsS

While browsing classic mystery films on YouTube, viewers may come across “The Ninth Guest,” a 1934 thriller based on the novel “The Invisible Host” by Gwen Bristow and Bruce Manning. The film bears a striking resemblance to Agatha Christie’s “And Then There Were None,” both the novel and its later film adaptations.

Photo poster for the 9th Guest

In “The Ninth Guest,” eight strangers are invited to a lavish New Orleans penthouse under mysterious circumstances. Once inside, a voice over the radio announces that they are all guilty of past misdeeds and will be killed before the night ends. The ninth guest, the voice declares, is death itself.

Christie’s “And Then There Were None,” published five years later in 1939, follows a similar structure. Ten individuals are summoned to a remote island, each accused of a crime that escaped legal punishment. A gramophone recording delivers the accusations, and the guests begin to die one by one, following the pattern of a nursery rhyme.

Both stories rely on isolation to build suspense. In “The Ninth Guest,” the guests are trapped in a locked penthouse with no way out. In Christie’s version, the island is cut off by weather and distance. The sense of confinement intensifies the psychological pressure as trust erodes and paranoia sets in.

The unseen host is another shared element. In both films, the killer remains anonymous until the final reveal, manipulating events from behind the scenes. The use of technology—radio in “The Ninth Guest,” gramophone in Christie’s story—adds a chilling layer of detachment.

While “The Ninth Guest” leans more toward theatrical pacing and direct confrontation, Christie’s work delves deeper into moral reckoning. Her characters are haunted by guilt, and the killer’s motive is philosophical: justice for the unpunished. Bristow and Manning’s version focuses more on revenge and survival.

The similarities are so pronounced that many viewers and scholars have speculated whether Christie was influenced by “The Invisible Host.” Though there is no confirmed link, the thematic overlap is undeniable. Both stories explore the consequences of hidden guilt, the fragility of trust, and the terrifying power of anonymity.

“The Ninth Guest” offers a glimpse into the evolution of suspense storytelling. The film serves as a reminder that even lesser-known works can cast long shadows, and that the line between inspiration and coincidence is often as mysterious as the stories themselves.

A big day today.

So tonight, I will be performing with my husband indoors, due to impending rain.

Anyway. I have to unload everything in the truck, so I can start loading speakers and equipment into the truck.

Each day is an entity unto itself for me.

I usually try to plan my to-do lists well in advance. But then it doesn’t seem like anything gets done.

Right now I do have to get started. So here’s the information regarding our gig tonight.

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/gJ6BrN6uPUZQKBjV/?mibextid=qi2Omg

Always an Anglophile

Our Memoir Writing Group

This morning it’s time for my memoir meeting so I wrote this little memoir called,
“Always an Anglophile” by Amy Zents

Growing up in Canada in the 1960s Queen Elizabeth’s regal picture adorned the walls of most public buildings, including my elementary classroom at Sprucecourt school in Toronto Ontario.
The United Kingdom, and especially England always fascinated me.
In 2011 my husband and I finally got a chance to go to England. We stayed in a lovely hotel in Russell square. Every morning we had hot tea and delicious bowls of oatmeal, along with hard boiled eggs to buck us up to face the cold November gales blowing hard in London. I couldn’t tell you how cold that wind was, but it was surprisingly cold!
One of the 1st places we visited was the Black Tower also known as the “Bloody Tower,” where the corpses of many innocent and executed people were buried.
The beefeater told us the story about Lady Jane Gray who was only 17, who ruled for a few days and then got her head chopped off.
We saw all the torture instruments as well as the prison cells and the grounds where the black crows like to fly.
Henry VIII and his huge weapons armory and arsenal was incredible as were the crown jewels.
Looking at the royal lineage testified to the reason there was so much fratricide and infantacide in the royal family as many grasped to be king or queen.
We went to Harrod’s and had afternoon tea there. It is a very beautiful expensive store gleaming with the finest things. We went down the escalator to see the memorial to Princesd Diana and Dodi Fayed.
After taking a train to Stratford we boarded a Double Decker bus to take us to Anne Hathaway’s cottage where Shakespeare lived.
After touring the home and grounds we left to go back to the city of Stratford on Avon to see a play called, “The Heart of Robin hood.”
We were the only 2 passengers on top of the open-air double-decker bus. With cheap plastic red headphones in each ear, we tried to listen to the tour commentator while going down the country roads at break neck speed!
We thought the driver must have been in a hurry to get to the pub!
After the play, it was late. We were the only people in the train station waiting for the train back to London. It was strangely quiet. Then another couple arrived later on and we watched them necking on a bench until the train arrived.
There are many fine tourist stops in London including the Sherlock Holmes museum and the Royal museum not to mention the beautiful Royal Albert hall where we went to hear a concert with the London Symphony.
Because I was so enamored with Charles Dickens at that time and reading all his books I did find it a great thrill to go to his house on Doughty street and examine memorabilia Including the desk he used to write the book “Great expectations.” Sadly, the famous painting I was hoping to see called, “The Dream,” featuring Pickwick, Little Doritt, David Copperfield and all the characters from his novels, was on loan to the Royal Museum and sitting in storage for when they put out their big 200th anniversary exhibit on Charles Dickens.
From the Royal Gallery to Buckingham palace,
from Hyde Park to the London Eye we walked or took a black cab, or the London Tube. We went so many places in so little time.
My husband’s thrill was the Royal Science Museum. Guides took us on a backstairs tour to see the many discoveries and actual writings on specimen bottles of Charles Darwin when he visited the Galapogos Islands.
Yes England was great and I guess I will always be an Anglophile.

CD was born on 2/7/1812

Did another number

Listen to Tim Finnegan Wake.m4a by Amy Zents on #SoundCloud
https://soundcloud.com/amyzents/tim-finnegan-wake-m4a?ref=clipboard&p=a&c=1&si=5ab1b1da0585437bbff144bd1a6eae69&utm_source=clipboard&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=social_sharing

Car Watch : Pontiac Trans Am

Two for the road

The Pontiac Trans Am is a sweet muscle car!

Blast from the past

Walking home this weekend I saw this golden beauty!

An old-fashioned classic convertible

Thursday Book Review: FDT

Coffee and goals

So what is future-directed therapy?

You want something special in your life? 😏

Something good to look forward to?

Then find the light at the end of your tunnel!

Find someone or something that brings you up.

Planning a vacation?

Really want to do or be something more?

It’s all up to you!

You choose.

You decide.

You discover.

Every Thursday I will give an inkling and quick review of what book I am reading, and/or studying. 📖

The book I am studying this week is called, “Think Forward to Thrive.”

It is an enlightening and enlivening book with a purpose.

It helps people discover meaningful goals to work towards.

Plan to be happy 😊

Some goals I’ve set for this summer.

Daily goals

Printing classes

Welcome friends!
Pressing times

We went to the open house.

The local arts center offers to teach the public the fine art of printing!

https://www.thegrandnewulm.com/cellar-press

The patience of these artists is amazing!

Fine artists
A display of beautuful prints

Benjamin Franklin was a printer.

You can be one too!

Moonlight and Music

Morgan Creek Vineyards

Last night my eclectic music duo, Molly and Sonny Boy performed at Morgan Creek Vineyards.

Sonny Boy with his Ukulele

It was perfect weather.

When the sun finally set, there was a clear sky and a beautiful moon.

Lovely moonlight

The food they provided after our gig was from an outdoor pizza oven.

Amazing stone deck oven-fired oven
Hubby and I near the fired up stone pizza oven!
Delicious meal
Vino made on site.
Hubby loved his mushroom calzone

All in all, it was a special time thanks to our generous George, Paula, Adam, Griffin, Dee and all the employees at Morgan Creek Vineyards!

https://www.morgancreekvineyards.com/

Saturday Gardens

Raised garden beds

I planted yellow squash, beets, cherry tomatoes and flowers in raised garden beds to keep the weeds down.

Hubby uses straw-bales as mulch as well, to keep weeds down to a minimum.

This year he is using plastic bottles to create mini-greehouses to keep the rabbits out!

Little terrariums

Right now green onions are on the table everyday in most every dish I cook.

Springtime is full of happy hours spent outside, even if it means repairing the outdoor spigot with plumbing thread tape and new washers.

Plants need fresh water too!

Better than Winter

Looking out my kitchen window

It was a long-time coming, but it looks like Spring has finally sprung!

To celebrate the joys of warmer weather, I brought home a stunningly beautiful Hydrangea plant.

A flowering Hydrangea plant
Beautuful Hydrangea 😍

They say being here in Minnesota is like living 6 months in Eden, and 6 months on Mars!

Well then, hypothetically-speaking, it looks like being here in May through October will be better than Winter!

The fountain is up and running now!